I tried them all, but one of them is my favorite.
I’ve been a Spotify user for years. It’s familiar, it’s comfortable, and honestly, it’s been my default background noise for everything from cleaning the house to late-night scrolling. But after a while, I started to feel a little… bored. My playlists felt repetitive, the recommendations weren’t surprising me anymore, and every price increase made me pause and think, “Is this really still the best option for me?”
So I decided to do a little experiment. For one full month, I rotated through five Spotify alternatives to see how they actually compare in real, everyday use — not just on paper. I paid close attention to the things that matter most when you’re listening daily: How easy is it to discover new music? Does the sound actually feel better? Is the app pleasant to use? And does it feel worth the money?
I used each app the same way I’d normally use Spotify — morning music, background playlists, downloads for offline listening, and the occasional deep dive into recommendations. No shortcuts, no skipping steps. Just real-life listening, one app at a time.
Apple Music — Best for Sound Quality and Apple Users
What I Loved
The very first thing I noticed with Apple Music was the sound quality. Even if you’re not an audiophile, you can tell the difference — songs feel fuller, richer, and more detailed, especially with headphones. Knowing that lossless and Spatial Audio are included at no extra cost made it feel like I was getting something genuinely premium.
I also loved how organized and calm the app feels. Apple Music leans heavily into your personal library, which made it feel more like my music collection instead of an endless stream of suggestions. Albums, artists, and playlists are easy to find, and nothing feels cluttered or overwhelming.
And if you’re already using Apple devices, the integration is seamless. Switching between my phone, laptop, and other devices felt effortless — everything just worked, without extra setup or frustration.
What Fell Short
That said, music discovery didn’t feel as natural as it does on Spotify. I had to be a bit more intentional about finding new music, rather than stumbling into it. The recommendations weren’t bad — just quieter, less playful, and not as immediately exciting.
The social side also felt limited. If you love sharing playlists, seeing what friends are listening to, or feeling that sense of connection through music, Apple Music might feel a little lonely by comparison.
Best For
Apple Music is a great choice if you truly care about how music sounds and enjoy a more polished, library-first experience. It’s especially appealing if you’re already deep in the Apple ecosystem and want everything to sync effortlessly without thinking about it.
YouTube Music — Best for Music Videos and Hidden Gems
What I Loved
Using YouTube Music felt like opening a door to a much bigger music universe. Suddenly, I wasn’t just listening to official album tracks — I was finding live performances, acoustic versions, covers, remixes, and even songs I didn’t realize weren’t on Spotify. If a song exists somewhere on YouTube, chances are you can listen to it here.
The recommendations were surprisingly good, especially if you already spend time on YouTube. It clearly pulls from what you watch as well as what you listen to, which made the suggestions feel more personal over time. After a few days, it started serving up artists and songs that felt very “me,” including older favorites I hadn’t thought about in years.
And of course, having official music videos built right in was a fun bonus. Sometimes I didn’t even realize how much I missed watching a video along with a song until it was right there, ready to play.
What Fell Short
The biggest downside for me was the interface. It can feel a little busy and cluttered, especially compared to Spotify’s clean layout. There’s a lot happening on the screen, and if you just want to press play and disappear into the music, it can feel distracting.
Also, if you’re someone who listens to music strictly as audio — while working, cooking, or relaxing — the heavy focus on video might feel unnecessary. I sometimes found myself thinking, “I just want the song, not the screen.”
Best For
YouTube Music is perfect if you love discovering rare tracks, live performances, and deep cuts that other platforms don’t always have. It’s especially worth it if you already pay for YouTube Premium, since it feels like a natural extension rather than a separate service.
Amazon Music — Best Value for Prime Members
What I Loved
Amazon Music really surprised me in one big way: how much you get if you’re already a Prime member. There’s a solid catalog included at no extra cost, which makes it feel like a bonus you didn’t even realize you were paying for.
The app itself is very straightforward. No fancy extras, no overwhelming features — just music. I actually appreciated how simple it felt. Finding albums, playlists, and downloads was easy, and offline listening worked smoothly without any headaches.
If you’re someone who just wants music on in the background without constantly fiddling with the app, Amazon Music does that job quietly and reliably.
What Fell Short
That simplicity, though, comes at a cost. Music discovery felt a bit flat compared to Spotify or YouTube Music. The playlists didn’t excite me, and I rarely felt that “wow, I love this song” moment that comes from great recommendations.
It also lacks personality. There’s nothing wrong with the app — it just doesn’t feel fun. If you enjoy curated playlists, social sharing, or feeling emotionally connected to your music app, this one might feel a little bland.
Best For
Amazon Music is ideal for Prime members who want a solid music experience without paying for yet another subscription. It’s also a great option for casual listeners who value simplicity over discovery and just want something that works without fuss.
Tidal — Best for Audiophiles and Artist Support
What I Loved
The first thing I noticed with Tidal was the sound — it’s not subtle. Songs felt cleaner, deeper, and more immersive, especially with good headphones. Little details stood out in tracks I’ve heard a hundred times before, and it honestly made me pause and think, “Wow… this is what this song is supposed to sound like.”
Beyond audio quality, I really appreciated Tidal’s artist-first approach. The platform clearly puts musicians front and center, and knowing that artists are paid more fairly made my listening feel a little more meaningful. It’s one of those small things that doesn’t change how the app works day-to-day, but it does change how you feel using it.
The app itself also has a very clean, premium vibe. No clutter, no chaos — just music presented in a calm, intentional way. It felt grown-up, polished, and focused, like a space designed for people who genuinely sit down and listen.
What Fell Short
That said, discovery wasn’t as exciting as I hoped. While the recommendations were good, they didn’t feel playful or surprising. I missed that “rabbit hole” feeling where you keep discovering new artists without trying.
The playlist ecosystem also felt smaller. If you rely heavily on user-created playlists or love browsing endless themed mixes, Tidal can feel a bit limited. It’s less social, less buzzy — more private and intentional.
Best For
Tidal is perfect for audiophiles or anyone who truly values sound quality. It’s also a great choice if you care about supporting artists and prefer a calm, premium listening experience over social features and constant discovery.
SoundCloud — Best for Indie and Emerging Artists
What I Loved
SoundCloud feels completely different from every other music app — in the best way possible. It’s raw, creative, and a little chaotic, like walking into a room where people are actually making music, not just consuming it.
This is where I found songs I couldn’t find anywhere else. Demos, early releases, experimental tracks, and artists who feel like they’re on the verge of something big. There’s a sense of discovery and originality that’s hard to match — you’re not just listening to polished hits, you’re hearing ideas in motion.
I also loved the community vibe. Seeing comments directly on tracks, watching artists interact with listeners, and feeling that direct connection made the experience feel personal and alive. It reminded me that music isn’t just content — it’s creativity.
What Fell Short
The downside? Quality can be inconsistent. Some tracks sound amazing, others clearly don’t — and you have to be okay with that. It’s not the app you open expecting perfectly mastered, radio-ready songs every time.
It’s also not ideal if you mostly listen to mainstream artists and chart hits. While they’re there, SoundCloud shines brightest when you’re open to exploring unknown names and unconventional sounds.
Best For
SoundCloud is perfect for indie music lovers, trend-seekers, and creators who want to be close to the creative process. If you enjoy discovering artists before they blow up and don’t mind a little messiness along the way, this app is incredibly rewarding.
Final Verdict: Which Spotify Alternative Actually Won?
After a full month of living inside five different apps, here’s the honest truth:
Spotify is still the easiest app to love — but it’s no longer the one that impressed me most.
If I had to pick just one alternative that genuinely made me rethink my loyalty, it would be Apple Music. The sound quality alone puts it ahead of Spotify, and once you hear that difference, it’s hard to go back. It feels calmer, more intentional, and more grown-up — like an app designed for people who actually listen to music, not just skim through it.
That said, Apple Music didn’t win on excitement.
If I’m choosing based purely on fun and discovery, YouTube Music was the most entertaining. It constantly surprised me with live versions, forgotten favorites, and songs I didn’t even know I was missing. It’s messy at times, yes — but it’s also the app that made me say, “Oh wow, I forgot how much I love this song.”
Tidal earned my respect but not my daily habit. The sound quality is incredible, and I genuinely admire its artist-first philosophy. But for everyday listening, it felt a little too serious — more like a listening room than a companion app I want on all day.
Amazon Music? Practical, reliable, and completely forgettable. If you already have Prime, it’s worth using. If you don’t, there’s nothing here that will make you switch.
And SoundCloud isn’t trying to compete at all — it’s in its own lane. It’s chaotic, creative, and thrilling if you love discovering new artists… but it’s not replacing Spotify for most people anytime soon.
So here’s my blunt takeaway:
- If you want better sound → switch to Apple Music
- If you want better discovery → try YouTube Music
- If you want fair artist support → Tidal
- If you want easy + familiar → Spotify still wins
- If you want creative chaos → SoundCloud
Would I cancel Spotify tomorrow? No.
Would I stop pretending it’s the best option for everyone? Absolutely.
Spotify is comfortable. Some of these alternatives are better — you just have to decide whether comfort or improvement matters more to you right now.
Read Also: